Episode 256 – I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025)/Bring Her Back

by The Grave Plot Podcast · January 22, 2026

Things are getting a little too hot this week on The Grave Plot Podcast.

Before we dive into reviews, we kick things off with Horror Business, including a truly bizarre Real World Horror story involving a family who believe they’ve been cursed after an encounter with a mysterious holy man… followed by a series of unexplained fires. Whether it’s supernatural, coincidence, or something far stranger, it’s the kind of story that feels ripped straight out of a horror movie.

From there, we run through a stacked batch of genre news, including the continued expansion of the Poohniverse, which is now barreling toward an all-out monster mash crossover. We also talk Mike Flanagan officially stepping into The Exorcist franchise, a sequel to the slasher Stream being penned by one of the Impractical Jokers, a Christmas-set Return of the Living Dead sequel shambling toward release, and Eli Roth teaming up with Snoop Dogg for a haunted house movie with a title that pretty much says it all.

Then it’s time for reviews. We revisit sun-drenched slasher nostalgia with 2025’s I Know What You Did Last Summer, breaking down whether this legacy sequel earns its resurrection or should’ve stayed buried. After that, we close things out with Bring Her Back, a much darker and more intimate horror film that gives us plenty to chew on.

So spark up your campfire stories, keep your cursed artifacts at arm’s length, and join us for another fresh descent into madness with The Grave Plot Podcast!